Recreation Commission hears results of first pool survey at Wednesday meeting

President of the Piedmont Swim Team Erin Schultz talks about the pool survey results

Piedmont residents really love their new pool, a city survey found, but how to prioritize and accommodate the many user groups who compete for time in the facility remains a challenge. “The first year of pool operations is really a period of learning and adjustments,” the city’s communications officer Echa Schneider said.

Schneider presented the results of a survey the city conducted from late August to mid-October that drew responses from 456 people. The good news: 82% rate their experience as good or excellent, and there was high praise for the pool staff. Nevertheless, the city said the survey highlighted areas that could be improved, and noted several adjustments that were made early on to manage high demand, such as capping summer pass sales, adding additional reserved swim times, and improving scheduling communications.

Four areas of improvement the city identified revolved around improving communications, reviewing some pool rules (ie, lowering the minimum age a child could swim unaccompanied), locker room comfort (adding more benches, hooks, etc.), and swim lesson accessibility (non-passholders frustrated). Schneider highlighted some user requests and complaints. “A key reason [for buying a pass] is to show up whenever is convenient for us within opening hours,” said one commenter. Others complained of a “bait and switch” as the city adjusted the schedule after passes were purchased.

Drop-in users are the least satisfied of all groups, the survey revealed, especially around pricing and uncertainty of being able to get in.

The survey didn’t ask about the needs of competitive and school programs. Piedmont Swim Team and water polo parents and students showed up to share their feedback at Wednesday’s meeting.

Erin Schultz, president of the Piedmont Swim Team, said the survey “didn’t really address the needs of youth athletes.” PST is on 3-month use agreements she said, and would like to return to a year+ agreement. She said the team also just learned that it’s losing its youth team discount due to low number of resident swimmers, which means a 25% rate increase, Schultz said. (In 2020, 152 of its 175 swimmers lived in Piedmont. Today it’s 66 of 192, a drop she attributes to six years without a pool.) PST would like, at minimum, six lanes from 4 p.m. – 7 p.m. she said, and needs a year+ agreement and to pay the youth rate.

Andrew Schultz said competitive users (water polo, high school and youth swimming, masters) will be “by far our highest utilization of the pool,” with five or six swimmers per lane — adding vibrancy to pool use. He warned against building policy around a small group of early-morning lap swimmers. “What I don’t want is this beautiful thing that we built to be this sterile entity that has six people swimming every morning,” while local kids shuttle all over the Bay Area to swim elsewhere, he said.

Resident Katie Van den Bos asked how PRD decides allocation, and whether it benchmarks against other East Bay pools.

Earlier in the meeting, PHS water polo players and several young PST swimmers spoke about what having a home pool means to them.

Colin Amen, PHS water polo team captain, spoke to the Rec Commission

At the meeting’s conclusion, Commissioner Sean Byrnes proposed a future agenda item to discuss “the right principles… for making these sorts of trade-off decisions.” He said it wouldn’t be about setting the schedule, but about giving guidance on what the community’s priorities should be.

The results of the Piedmont pool survey is available for review HERE. (Click the “Feedback” tab and “Both” for full results.)

Leave a Reply

The Exedra comments section is an essential part of the site. The goal of our comments policy is to help ensure it is a vibrant yet civil space. To participate, we ask that Exedra commenters please provide a first and last name. Please note that comments expressing congratulations or condolences may be published without full names. (View our full Comments Policy.)

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *