Top Takeaways
- Researchers with opposing views on the usefulness of the SAT presented their cases to UC’s Board of Regents.
- One researcher said the tests are a better predictor of college success than grades. Another said the tests would mainly serve to advantage wealthy students.
- Outside the regents meeting, students held a press conference pushing back against the exams.
The University of California’s Board of Regents on Tuesday heard competing views over the usefulness of standardized tests as it weighs whether to reinstate the SAT and ACT exams in admissions.
At the board meeting in San Francisco, one researcher from Brown University argued that the SAT is a useful tool for predicting academic preparation. A UC Berkeley researcher, meanwhile, contended the tests would provide little value in admissions and mostly serve to advantage wealthier students.
The regents did not take any action. They are expected to make a decision in summer 2027.
“Our role as regents is to understand the evidence and prepare for future considerations of any recommendations,” Maria Anguiano, chair of the board, said.
Some UC faculty have said reinstating the exams would help campuses determine whether students are prepared for UC coursework, especially in science, technology, engineering and math programs. They point to worsening levels of preparedness among incoming first-year students in recent years, including declining performance in introductory math classes.
Others have argued that reinstating the exams is not the solution and that the declining levels of preparation is rooted in high schools. UC Davis researchers published a report this week showing a steady decline in the share of UC enrollees who completed advanced math courses in high school since 2017 — years before UC got rid of the SAT.
What the research says
John Friedman, a professor of economics at Brown University, shared research with the regents that explored the relationship between test scores and high school grades with college grades, using data from Ivy League and other highly selective universities.
Comparing students of the same race, socioeconomic status and gender, Friedman’s research found that students with the highest possible SAT or ACT score had GPAs that were 0.43 points higher than students who scored in the 75th percentile on the tests.
Meanwhile, his research showed a “much weaker” link between high school GPA and college grades.
“I think it’s clear that there’s predictive information that’s useful above and beyond what the information is in high school grades in assessing academic preparation,” Friedman said.
The regents then heard from Jesse Rothstein, a professor of public policy and economics at UC Berkeley, where he also directs the Center for Studies in Higher Education.
Rothstein said the SAT “does somewhat help” in predicting college grades, “but it does so at a direct cost to access for students from underrepresented groups and disadvantaged backgrounds.”
Rothstein shared data showing that, since eliminating the SAT and ACT in admissions, UC’s Berkeley, Los Angeles and San Diego campuses have admitted higher shares of students who are Black, Latino or American Indian.
Rothstein also cautioned against comparing UC to Ivy League institutions, noting that the UC system has “a different mission.”
“We accomplish our mission very well in ways that the Ivy League doesn’t, and that calls for different admissions policies,” Rothstein said.
Students push back
At the press conference outside the board meeting, student leaders and advocacy groups argued that the SAT’s flaws outweigh its benefits.
Candice Phan, the UC Student Association president, said requiring the test “closes the doors on students from communities of color and low-income backgrounds.”
Phan also said faculty calls to reinstate high-stakes tests overlook “the nuanced global context which we are in.” She pointed to impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic, teacher shortages and the growing presence of artificial intelligence in K-12 systems.
“So rather than blaming students, the UC needs to look itself in the mirror, assess the landscape and timeline which we are in, and decide how we are to move forward in a way that truly centers student experience, equity, and access,” Phan said.

This story was originally published by EdSource.