Top Takeaways
- A new report from UC Davis researchers shows a steady decline, since 2017, in the share of University of California students who entered college having taken precalculus or calculus in high school.
- The findings may help explain the worsening math preparedness of incoming UC freshmen.
- UC’s admissions board will consider the findings as it weighs whether to recommend that the university system reinstate the SAT and ACT in freshman admissions.
Fewer students are entering the University of California having completed an advanced math course in high school, a decline that has steadily worsened over the past decade, according to a new report.
The report, published Monday evening by UC Davis researchers, shows double-digit declines since 2017 in the share of entering freshmen who took at least precalculus in high school, including among science, technology, engineering and math (STEM) majors. Researchers found that the share of students who completed calculus before enrolling declined by an even greater amount.
The findings, shared this month with UC’s admissions board, provide another possible explanation for the deteriorating levels of math preparedness among UC freshmen as UC leaders weigh whether to reinstate the SAT and ACT exams in admissions.
The researchers also investigated high school grade point averages as a predictor of success at UC and, despite concerns about grade inflation, found no declines in the predictive power of high school GPAs.
To critics of the SAT, the findings are evidence that UC’s math preparation issues are rooted in high schools and won’t be completely fixed by reinstating the tests.
“It’s really hard to reconcile this decline with the idea that if only we had the SAT, we could do a better job of identifying people who are going to have the math preparation to succeed in STEM,” said Jesse Rothstein, a professor of public policy and economics at UC Berkeley who also directs Berkeley’s Center for Studies in Higher Education.
“Either we’re choosing not to prioritize the coursework in admissions, in which case that would be the way to fix underpreparedness, or we are prioritizing it and there just aren’t as many students out there who meet that criteria, in which case the SAT isn’t going to help because those students just aren’t there,” Rothstein added.
UC stopped using the SAT and ACT in admissions in 2020 following concerns that the tests were inequitable and disproportionately benefited students of higher socioeconomic statuses.
Many UC math faculty argue that reinstating the tests is necessary, at least for STEM applicants, because the scores would help campuses assess whether a student can handle rigorous college math course sequences. In recent years, the percentage of freshmen failing or struggling in introductory math courses has spiked at many campuses.
UC’s Board of Admissions and Relations with Schools (BOARS) is scheduled to make a recommendation by Feb. 12 on whether the tests should be reinstated. The final decision will be up to the Board of Regents.
Michal Kurlaender, one of the UC Davis researchers and faculty director of the California Education Lab at Davis, presented the new findings to BOARS at its Nov. 6 meeting. BOARS officials were not available Tuesday for an interview.
A decadelong decline in precalculus and calculus rates
Earlier this year, Kurlaender and a team of researchers published a report showing a statewide decline in the percentage of students in California public high schools taking precalculus or calculus, from 45.9% of students in the class of 2017 to 33.4% of students in the class of 2024.
The report published Tuesday offers the first examination of those course-taking patterns specifically among students who enrolled at UC.
Among students who entered UC in 2024 from a California public high school, 82.6% of them had taken precalculus or calculus, either in high school or via dual enrollment, according to the report. That was down from 94.7% of students who entered UC in 2017. The share of students who had completed calculus declined from 71.1% to 57.3% over that same period.
The declines were just as significant among STEM majors, which account for more than 40% of UC undergraduates. The freshman class of 2024, for example, included about 22,000 students, or 42%, who declared a STEM major, according to UC data.
Of the STEM majors who enrolled in 2024 from a California public high school, 86.5% of them had completed at least precalculus, down from 96.7% in 2017. The percentage of STEM majors who had completed calculus dropped from 79.8% to 65.5%.
The report doesn’t explore what caused those declines, but one force likely driving them is the shortage of qualified high school math teachers, said Linda Darling-Hammond, president of the California State Board of Education.
“You can’t offer as many courses and you can’t offer them as well if they’re being taught by folks who are not credentialed and not actually deeply knowledgeable about math,” Darling-Hammond said. “If we want to improve readiness, we need to have well-designed courses that are well taught.”
Kurlaender suggested that UC work with the state to ensure that courses are available and that UC make it clear to students and families that taking the classes will better prepare them for UC coursework.
If high schools don’t have the capacity to offer the classes, they should consider partnering with nearby community colleges and offering them through dual enrollment, Kurlaender added.
“All of these things would go much further toward the larger preparation problem that has been identified over this past year,” she said.
Grades as a predictor of UC success
Some UC faculty have argued that the SAT and ACT are a necessary data point in admissions because grade inflation has made grade point averages less of a useful indicator.
Davis researchers examined the correlation between high school GPA and first-year college GPA and found that high school GPA has remained at least as strong of a predictor as it was before the pandemic.
“There’s been a lot of conjecture that post-pandemic grade inflation has fundamentally changed the relationship between high school GPA and first-year college outcomes, and we do not find that to be the case,” Kurlaender said.

This story was originally published by EdSource.